A cruise ship follows a screen 17 miles off course

Why the screen matters10 June 1995

When a GPS antenna cable came loose, a cruise ship’s bridge displays kept showing a normal-looking position for about 34 hours while the ship drifted off course. Officers trusted the screen until the ship ran aground.

Position
The integrated bridge display
Effect
Deceive

What happened

The passenger ship Royal Majesty left Bermuda for Boston on 9 June 1995 with 1,509 people aboard. Less than an hour later the GPS antenna cable came apart, and the receiver fell back to dead reckoning without correcting for wind or current. For about 34 hours the bridge displays showed a position that looked normal. The only signs were a one-second beep and small letters on the GPS display, which no watch officer noticed. Lookouts reported lights and then blue and white water ahead; no one acted. At about 22:25 on 10 June the ship grounded on a shoal near Nantucket, about 17 nautical miles from where the officers believed it was. No one was hurt. The NTSB blamed over-reliance on the automated bridge system, along with training and design.

The ATG nexus

Not an attack. The case is in the corpus as a lesson in automation bias: skilled people acted on a trusted screen and discounted the evidence of their own eyes. A false track placed on a display on purpose would meet the same trust, from people trained to rely on it.

Limits of the comparison

The failure was accidental and the screen did give a weak warning. Nobody chose what the display would show.

On this site

Sources

  1. Grounding of the Panamanian Passenger Ship Royal Majesty on Rose and Crown Shoal (DCA95MM042, MAR-97-01)NTSBPrimary source
  2. Marine Accident Report NTSB/MAR-97/01 (archived)NTSB via UNT Web Archive, 1997Primary source
  3. Why-Because Analysis of the Royal Majesty grounding (draft, based on NTSB/MAR-97/01)RVS Group, University of Bielefeld, 7 July 2003

Back to this event on the timeline