Uber’s Greyball shows officials a fake version of its app

Why the screen matters3 March 2017

The New York Times revealed that Uber identified regulators and officials and served them a fake version of its app, with ghost cars or none, so that enforcement stings would fail.

Position
The company’s own app, deciding per user what to show
Effect
Deceive

What happened

On 3 March 2017 the New York Times, citing current and former employees, reported that Uber used a tool called Greyball, part of a wider program, to identify officials trying to catch its drivers in places where it was restricted. Signals included geofencing around enforcement offices, payment cards tied to institutions such as police credit unions, device identifiers and social media. Flagged users were served a fake version of the app with ghost cars or none, and any matched driver would cancel. It was used in Portland and other cities and countries. Uber said it would stop using it against regulators, and Reuters reported a Justice Department investigation.

The ATG nexus

Not a supply-chain event. It is the clearest public case of a screen built to show one chosen viewer a different reality from everyone else, by the party that controls the application. The research's targeting concern is exactly this logic run by someone positioned inside a trusted app's supply chain rather than its owner.

Limits of the comparison

The owner of the app did it to its own product. No charges over Greyball were reported in the sources cited.

On this site

Sources

  1. Uber reportedly used secret tool to avoid authorities in cities where it was restricted, including Boston (NYT report)The Boston Globe (reprinting The New York Times), 3 March 2017
  2. Uber Greyball secret programFortune, 3 March 2017
  3. U.S. Department of Justice is reportedly investigating Uber's controversial 'Greyball' programTechCrunch, 5 May 2017

Back to this event on the timeline