ISP middleboxes inject spyware and ads into downloads
ATG-class event9 March 2018
Citizen Lab found network appliances on Turkish and Egyptian networks redirecting users’ plain-HTTP downloads of ordinary software to spyware-laden copies, and injecting ad and cryptocurrency-mining redirects into pages.
- Position
- Deep-packet-inspection appliances inside national ISP networks
- Reach
- 259 targeted IP addresses in Turkey over five months; 1,239 IPs in 17 networks in one Egyptian scan
- Category
- Network-Position Injection
What happened
In March 2018 Citizen Lab reported that deep-packet-inspection middleboxes, which it matched to Sandvine PacketLogic devices, on Türk Telekom's network were redirecting users who downloaded legitimate Windows software over plain HTTP. At least ten applications were affected, among them common antivirus, browser and archiving tools. Instead of the real installer, targeted users received a copy bundled with government-grade spyware. Citizen Lab counted 259 targeted IP addresses in Turkey over five months, and users in Syria were reached through service relayed from Turkish subscribers.
In Egypt, middleboxes at a Telecom Egypt boundary redirected users to affiliate advertising and to browser cryptocurrency-mining scripts. Sandvine called the report false and misleading and denied its devices could inject payloads.
The ATG nexus
The user asked a trusted publisher for a trusted program and received something else, chosen for them by IP address. The publisher was never compromised. The substitution happened in the network the user paid for, after the user's decision and before delivery. That is the network-position category of the confirmed record, applied to individuals and paid for by a state, alongside a commercial use of the same position to take over users' pages for ad revenue and computing power.
Limits of the comparison
The injection worked only on unencrypted downloads and page loads, and it did not break HTTPS. The report identifies targeted IP addresses, which are not a count of people or devices.
On this site
- Whitepaper, Chapter 13: The Confirmed Historical Record
- Introduction: Anyone in Position
- Concept: No Network Is Structurally Immune
- Concept: Conscripted Trust
- Concept: The Compute Tax