Preinstalled adware breaks HTTPS to inject ads into pages

Placement and access19 February 2015

Lenovo laptops shipped with adware that installed its own root certificate to inject ads into encrypted web pages, with a private key anyone could extract, exposing every affected user to interception.

Position
Software preinstalled by the device manufacturer
Reach
About 750,000 laptops in the US (press reporting)

What happened

From late 2014 Lenovo preinstalled Superfish's VisualDiscovery adware on consumer laptops. It injected product ads into web pages, including encrypted ones. To reach inside HTTPS pages it installed its own root certificate and re-signed sites' certificates, acting as a man in the middle on the user's own machine. In February 2015 a researcher extracted the private key, protected by the same easily cracked password on every laptop, which meant anyone could impersonate secure sites to affected users. Lenovo stopped shipping it and published removal tools. In 2017 it settled with the FTC and 32 states, paying $3.5 million to the states and agreeing to a long-term software security program.

The ATG nexus

The manufacturer's position on the device came before anything the user installed or any site they visited. From there, third-party code rewrote the pages people read, and did it inside connections the browser reported as secure. The case is a precursor in two ways: content injected into pages from a trusted position, and a defense, encryption, silently bypassed by the party the user had no reason to doubt.

Limits of the comparison

The injected content was advertising, visible as such. The danger to users came from the weak key, which exposed them to others, rather than from deliberate deception by the vendor.

On this site

Sources

  1. Lenovo Settles FTC Charges it Harmed Consumers With Preinstalled Software on its Laptops that Compromised Online SecurityU.S. Federal Trade Commission, 5 September 2017Primary source
  2. Lenovo caves in face of public firestorm, releases Superfish killerThe Register, 20 February 2015
  3. Lenovo FTC Superfish settlement approvedThe Register, 2 January 2018
  4. Lenovo settles adware case with FTC, 32 statesCyberScoop, September 2017

Back to this event on the timeline